Protein quality comparison
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Protein Quality Comparison: Key Metrics and Methods
Protein quality is determined by both amino acid composition and digestibility. The most widely used metrics for assessing protein quality are the Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS) and the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS). These scores consider not only the presence of essential amino acids but also how well the body can digest and utilize them. Methods based on ileal digestibility (DIAAS) are generally preferred over those based on fecal digestibility (PDCAAS), as they provide a more accurate estimate of protein quality. Additionally, the effects of food processing and the food matrix can significantly impact protein digestibility and quality, making it important to evaluate proteins in their consumed form, not just in isolation Gaudichon2024Adhikari2022Tormási2025.
Animal vs. Plant Protein Quality
Animal-sourced proteins, such as casein, whey, pork meat, and egg, consistently rank as high- or excellent-quality proteins, with DIAAS values often above 75 or even 100. These proteins typically contain all essential amino acids in sufficient quantities and have high digestibility. For example, calcium caseinate and whey protein concentrate have the highest essential amino acid content and meet or exceed FAO quality standards Corgneau2019Herreman2020Han2015+1 MORE.
In contrast, most plant-based proteins, including pea, rice, oat, hemp, and fava bean, have lower DIAAS values (often below 75), indicating lower quality. This is usually due to the presence of limiting essential amino acids and/or lower digestibility. However, some plant proteins, such as potato protein, can achieve high DIAAS scores and are considered excellent quality Herreman2020Han2015Nosworthy2017.
Alternative and Emerging Protein Sources
Yeast protein, a microbial protein, shows promise as a sustainable alternative. It has a high ratio of indispensable to dispensable amino acids and better amino acid scores than most plant proteins, but its digestibility is still lower than that of animal proteins, resulting in intermediate overall quality . Seaweed proteins, such as those from Ulva fenestrata, can be extracted with good yield and solubility, and their digestibility is comparable across different extraction methods, suggesting potential as alternative protein sources .
Protein Blends and Complementarity
No single plant protein source meets all dietary requirements for essential amino acids. However, combining different plant proteins—such as legumes, cereals, and microalgae—can complement each other's amino acid profiles, resulting in blends with no limiting amino acids and improved overall quality. For example, blends of pea and corn protein, supplemented with barley or microalgae, can achieve high nutritional quality Herreman2020Broucke2024. This strategy is essential for optimizing plant-based diets.
Protein Quality in Processed Foods
The protein quality of processed foods, such as protein bars, can be significantly lower than that of pure protein isolates. The inclusion of lower-quality proteins (e.g., collagen) and other ingredients (carbohydrates, fats, fibers) can reduce the bioaccessibility and digestibility of essential amino acids, resulting in lower DIAAS and PDCAAS values—even when the product is labeled "high in protein" .
Conclusion
Animal proteins generally offer the highest protein quality due to their complete amino acid profiles and high digestibility. Most plant proteins are of lower quality individually, but strategic blending can overcome their limitations. Alternative proteins like yeast and seaweed are promising but still lag behind animal proteins in digestibility. The food matrix and processing methods can further impact protein quality, highlighting the importance of evaluating proteins as they are consumed. Understanding and optimizing protein quality is crucial for designing healthy, sustainable diets, especially as the demand for alternative protein sources grows Corgneau2019Herreman2020Han2015+6 MORE.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic