Over-the-counter cold medications
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Overview of Over-the-Counter Cold Medications: Efficacy and Safety
Over-the-counter (OTC) cold medications are widely used to relieve symptoms of the common cold, including cough, nasal congestion, sore throat, and fever. These products include analgesics, decongestants, antihistamines, antitussives, expectorants, mucolytics, and combination products. While they are popular and easily accessible, their effectiveness and safety—especially in children—are subjects of ongoing debate and concern Eccles2009Edwards2023Smith1993.
Efficacy of OTC Cold Medications in Adults and Adolescents
Analgesics and Decongestants for Symptom Relief
Analgesics such as aspirin, paracetamol (acetaminophen), and ibuprofen are commonly used to reduce pain and fever during a cold, with their efficacy and safety supported by data from other pain models . Nasal decongestants like pseudoephedrine have demonstrated effectiveness in relieving nasal congestion in clinical trials, providing rapid short-term relief Eccles2009Edwards2023Smith1993+1 MORE. Combination therapies, such as antihistamine-decongestant mixes, have also been shown to relieve a variety of cold symptoms in adolescents and adults .
Antihistamines and Antitussives
First-generation antihistamines (e.g., chlorpheniramine) may help with rhinorrhea and can be considered for patients whose symptoms interfere with sleep Edwards2023Douhard2024. However, the evidence supporting the efficacy of antihistamines and antitussives (such as dextromethorphan) is limited and sometimes controversial Eccles2009Edwards2023Smith1993. Dextromethorphan is recommended for cough relief, but its overall benefit remains debated .
Expectorants, Mucolytics, and Other Remedies
There is little clinical support for the efficacy of expectorants and mucolytics in treating cold symptoms . Menthol and hot drinks can provide immediate and sustained relief for symptoms like cough and sore throat, though much of the perceived benefit may be due to placebo effects .
Efficacy and Safety in Children
Lack of Efficacy and Potential Risks
Multiple studies confirm a lack of evidence supporting the effectiveness of OTC cold medications in children, especially in those under six years old Smith1993Gunn2001Vassilev2010+2 MORE. In preschool children, studies have shown no symptom relief, and even in older children, benefits are inconsistent . Despite this, these medications are still frequently prescribed and used in young children and infants, often against regulatory recommendations Vassilev2010Carr2006Asif2020.
Adverse Effects and Toxicity
OTC cold medications can cause significant adverse effects in children, including arrhythmias, hallucinations, central nervous system depression, and even death, particularly with incorrect dosing or chronic use Gunn2001Vassilev2010Carr2006+1 MORE. Serious adverse events, while rare, continue to be reported, leading to strong recommendations against their use in infants and very young children Gunn2001Vassilev2010Carr2006+1 MORE.
Misuse and Abuse of OTC Cold Medications
Trends in Misuse
OTC cold medications, especially those containing dextromethorphan and certain antihistamines, are increasingly misused for recreational purposes, particularly among adolescents and young adults Schifano2021Levine2007. This misuse can lead to both physical and psychiatric toxicity, dependence, and withdrawal syndromes Schifano2021Levine2007. The easy accessibility and low perceived risk contribute to this growing problem Schifano2021Levine2007.
Need for Vigilance
Healthcare professionals are urged to be vigilant about the potential for misuse and to educate patients and caregivers about the risks associated with OTC cold medications Schifano2021Levine2007.
Conclusion
OTC cold medications are widely used for symptom relief in adults and adolescents, with some evidence supporting the use of analgesics and decongestants. However, their efficacy in children is unproven, and the risk of adverse effects is significant, especially in young children. Misuse and abuse of these medications are growing concerns, particularly among adolescents. Healthcare providers should carefully consider the risks and benefits when recommending these products and prioritize patient education and safety.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic