Health effects of vaping vs smoking
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Lung Health Effects: Vaping vs Smoking
Both vaping and smoking are linked to negative effects on lung health. Studies show that vaping can cause lung injuries, such as EVALI (e-cigarette or vaping-associated lung injury), and may impair lung function similarly to smoking. Both habits are associated with reduced lung capacity, bronchoconstriction, and structural changes in the lungs, as seen in both animal and human studies. Vaping is not free from risk and may lead to various lung diseases, especially in young adults, despite being marketed as a safer alternative to smoking Darabseh2020Darabseh2021Rahim2024+1 MORE.
Lung Cancer Risk: Combined and Individual Use
Research indicates that the risk of lung cancer is significantly higher in individuals who both vape and smoke compared to those who only smoke. The odds of developing lung cancer are over three to four times higher for people who use both products, even after adjusting for other health conditions. This increased risk is consistent across different genders and types of lung cancer. The addition of vaping to smoking appears to accelerate the risk of developing lung cancer, suggesting that dual use is particularly harmful Bittoni2024Bittoni2024Rahim2024.
Cardiovascular Health: Vaping and Smoking Comparisons
Both vaping and smoking negatively impact cardiovascular health. Vaping causes oxidative stress, inflammation, and endothelial dysfunction, which are also seen with smoking. The toxic compounds in e-cigarette vapor overlap significantly with those in cigarette smoke, leading to similar damage to blood vessels. Some evidence suggests that vaping may even increase platelet reactivity more than smoking, which could raise the risk of cardiovascular events. Overall, both habits impair vascular function to a similar extent Darabseh2020Daiber2023Metzen2021.
Respiratory and Muscle Function
Vaping and smoking both reduce lung function, as measured by spirometry tests. Both groups show lower forced expiratory volume and peak expiratory flow compared to non-users. While some measures are slightly worse in smokers, the overall impact of vaping on respiratory function is similar to that of smoking. The effects on muscle function are less clear, but both habits may contribute to declines in muscle health over time Darabseh2020Darabseh2021.
Vaping as a Smoking Cessation Aid
Vaping is sometimes used as a tool to help people quit smoking. Clinical trials suggest that vaping can be effective for smoking cessation and is associated with fewer adverse events than continued smoking. However, the long-term health effects of vaping remain unknown, and the potential for dual use (vaping and smoking together) may undermine its benefits Ashour2023Ruffin2024.
Pregnancy and Fetal Health Outcomes
The health effects of vaping during pregnancy are not well understood. Some studies suggest that exclusive vaping may pose a similar risk to exclusive smoking for various maternal and infant outcomes, while others find no increased risk compared to non-use. However, the quality of evidence is low, and many women who vape during pregnancy have also smoked, making it difficult to draw firm conclusions .
Conclusion
Current research shows that both vaping and smoking have significant negative health effects, particularly on lung and cardiovascular health. Vaping is not a risk-free alternative to smoking and may cause similar or, in some cases, even greater harm, especially when combined with smoking. While vaping may help some people quit smoking, its long-term safety is still uncertain. Public health interventions should address the risks of both habits, especially among young people and pregnant women.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic