Formation of the first planets
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Metallicity and the Formation of the First Planets
The formation of the first planets in the universe is closely tied to the metallicity of their host stars and protoplanetary disks. High metallicity is crucial because heavy elements are needed to form dust grains, which then settle and coagulate into planetesimals—the building blocks of planets. Observations and models suggest a critical metallicity threshold for planet formation, with a lower limit of about [Fe/H] ≈ -1.5 + log(r/1 AU), where r is the orbital distance. This means that the first Earth-like planets likely formed in disks with metallicities at least 10% that of the Sun. If planets are found around stars with even lower metallicities, it would challenge the core accretion model of planet formation Johnson2012Eriksson2025.
Early Stages: Dust Growth and Planetesimal Formation in Young Disks
Recent research shows that planet formation can begin very early, during the Class 0/I phases of star formation, when the star and disk are still embedded in an infalling envelope. In these young disks, dust grains can grow rapidly through collisional processes, forming millimeter-sized grains and even kilogram-sized pebbles within 0.1 million years. This early grain growth is essential because it creates the conditions for the streaming instability, a process that can quickly form planetesimals if the dust-to-gas ratio is high enough. The efficiency of this process depends on the size of the dust grains and the dynamics of the collapsing protostellar cloud, with a "sweet spot" for grain sizes of a few tens of microns Cridland2021Harsono2018Xu2023.
Role of Disk Substructures and Vortices in the First Planet Formation
Disk substructures, such as rings, gaps, and vortices, play a significant role in concentrating dust and facilitating planetesimal formation. Vortices, in particular, can trap and concentrate dust, lowering the metallicity threshold needed for planetesimal formation. Simulations indicate that planetesimals can form at metallicities as low as 4% of the Sun's metallicity if vortices are present, and Mercury-mass planets can form under these conditions. However, forming larger planets like Mars requires higher metallicities, and increased disk turbulence raises the threshold further Eriksson2025Ohashi2023.
Chemical Signatures and Locations of the First Planetesimals
The chemical composition of the earliest planetesimals provides clues about where and how they formed. Studies of meteorites suggest that the first inner Solar System planetesimals formed beyond the water snowline, where water-bearing materials could be incorporated, leading to more oxidized compositions. This widespread formation of oxidized, water-rich planetesimals in the early inner Solar System suggests that water played a key role in the earliest stages of planet formation .
Challenges and Open Questions in Early Planet Formation
Despite significant progress, several challenges remain in understanding the formation of the first planets. Key bottlenecks include the detailed processes of dust growth, the transition from dust to planetesimals, and the influence of disk structure and evolution. The relationship between observed disk substructures and actual planet formation, especially in very low mass stars and brown dwarfs, is still being explored. Observations show that substructures are common even in disks around these low-mass objects, but forming giant planets in such environments is particularly challenging due to rapid dust drift and low disk masses Morbidelli2016Pinilla2022.
Conclusion
The formation of the first planets began early in the history of the universe, requiring a minimum level of metallicity and favorable disk conditions for dust growth and planetesimal formation. Early planet formation is facilitated by processes like the streaming instability and the presence of disk substructures such as vortices. Chemical evidence points to the importance of water-rich materials in the earliest planetesimals. While much has been learned, ongoing observations and modeling are needed to fully understand the complex pathways that led to the first planets.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic