Black hole volume calculation
Pro Research Analysisby 
Searched over 200M research papers
Black Hole Volume Calculation: Definitions and Approaches
Calculating the volume inside a black hole is a complex problem because, unlike the surface area of the event horizon, the interior volume depends on the choice of spacelike hypersurface and the coordinate system used. This means the volume is not uniquely defined and can vary depending on the method of calculation .
Maximal Hypersurface and Interior Volume
A widely used approach is to define the black hole's interior volume as the volume of the largest spacelike hypersurface bounded by the event horizon. For a non-rotating (Schwarzschild) black hole, this maximal hypersurface is found at a specific radius, and its volume grows with the advanced time coordinate, even as the black hole evaporates and its area shrinks . This method has been extended to charged and rotating black holes, as well as to higher-dimensional and lower-dimensional (such as BTZ) black holes 2346.
For rotating (Kerr) black holes, the calculation is more complicated due to the axial symmetry. However, studies show that a hypersurface at constant radius is very close to the maximal hypersurface, and the effect of rotation on the volume is limited. Thus, the volume of this hypersurface is a good approximation for the interior volume of a Kerr black hole . Similar techniques are used for charged and rotating BTZ black holes in 2+1 dimensions, where the maximal volume depends on mass, angular momentum, and the AdS length scale 36.
Thermodynamic Volume and Cosmological Constant
In the context of black hole thermodynamics, the concept of "thermodynamic volume" arises when the cosmological constant is treated as a thermodynamic variable. The thermodynamic volume is defined as the conjugate variable to the cosmological constant in the extended first law of black hole thermodynamics. This volume is proportional to a parameter Θ, which can be calculated for various black hole solutions, including charged and rotating black holes in higher dimensions 15. The thermodynamic volume often matches the naive geometric volume in certain cases, such as the region between the black hole and cosmological horizons in de Sitter spacetimes .
Isoperimetric and Reverse Isoperimetric Inequalities
Research has also explored inequalities relating the black hole's volume and horizon area. The "Reverse Isoperimetric Inequality" conjectures that, for a given thermodynamic volume, the entropy (proportional to the horizon area) is maximized for the Schwarzschild-AdS black hole. This is the opposite of the usual isoperimetric inequality in Euclidean space, where the sphere maximizes volume for a given surface area 15.
Vector Volume and Alternative Definitions
Another approach introduces the "vector volume," which uses divergence-free vector fields to define an invariant volume for a spacetime region. This method is particularly useful in stationary, axially symmetric spacetimes and provides a flexible way to define black hole volumes, connecting geometric and thermodynamic perspectives .
Conclusion
The calculation of black hole volume is not unique and depends on the chosen definition and context. The maximal hypersurface approach provides a geometric volume that grows with time, while the thermodynamic volume links black hole physics to thermodynamics, especially when considering a variable cosmological constant. Both approaches have been generalized to various black hole types and dimensions, and ongoing research continues to refine these concepts and explore their implications for black hole entropy and information 1234+6 MORE.
Sources and full results
Most relevant research papers on this topic